Thoughts 
by Sarah Winman, GPPutnam’s Sons 2017, 214 pages
MOTIVATION for READING: Nancy said I would like it. I had already added this to my tbr so some nice blurb somewhere must have caught my attention.
WHAT’s it ABOUT: This is a story about friendship and love. All the kinds of love. We meet two young boys who both suffer losses and become true friends; then one meets a lovely girl (who runs a bookstore! squeee – always a bonus in a book, right?) and then the three become great friends and become family. And then…
WHAT’s GOOD: Everything. It’s told well, the imagery and settings across England and Europe, the conversations, the happenings, all touching in all the right ways.
What’s NOT so good: I give this 4 stars and maybe because it can be a sad book. But it can also be a hopeful book, it’s life. Maybe I just didn’t quite get all the buttons pushed when I love a reading experience but this one is delightful and I heartily recommend. Maybe it isn’t a 5 star because I wanted it to be longer? That’s nuts, but … oh well.
FINAL THOUGHTS: If you like ART and love your stories to involve grand gorgeous paintings by the master and love that imagery – this is a story for you. If you love love stories, sort of love stories, enjoy your heart getting involved – maybe stomped on a bit, then this is a story for you.
Come on, the title? TIN MAN. He has a heart… Now, I’ve piqued your interest. Admit it.
RATING: Four slices of pie with lots of whipped cream. Or gravy. This book is inspiring me to make more savory pies this fall. Mmmmmmm
“Potatoes, wine, a ham and a pork pie and salad, a feast.”
“But then he said, pie and chips, Janice, please. And she said, pie and chips it is then. There you go, my love.”
“The canteen was busy and smelled of chips and shepherds pie and something over-cooked and green.”
THANKS NANCY!!!
Wishing a book were longer is a good thing. I do love art so need to look for this book.
I liked it. Hope you do, too.
I think you liked this a bit more than I did. Trying to think of the last time I wished a book could be longer… 😉
I also liked it for the lovely deckled edges. It’s the little things.
I loved this one and thought it was just beautiful. It was meant to be sad because that is indeed life, but oh, such emotion. So gorgeously written!
We agree!
It will most likely be one of my faves for the year. Short but so full of goodness. I really enjoyed the writing.
We agree, too!
I disliked When God Was a Rabbit by Winman so I am hesitant about this title and will likely skip it. But that’s OK ’cause it frees me up to read some other lovely book, right? 🙂
Exactly!
There definitely was a bit of heart stomping involved. Glad you enjoyed it!
Pingback: Review 2018 – Care's Books and Pie