Wide Sargasso Sea #ccspin

Wide Sargasso Sea by Jean Rhys, Norton 2016 (org 1966), 174 Pages

Introduction by Edwidge Danticat (read last, though, of course. I adhere to a strict policy of never reading Intros until I read the text. Ahem)

Challenge: For this month’s Classic Club Spin.

Genre: Fan-Fiction? Carribean Historical Fiction, an Anti-Romance, perhaps.

Type/Source: Tradeback / I finally had the opportunity and forethought to plan for a shopping trip to an Indie Bookstore who to my excitement and delight had a copy for me to purchase!

Will ship to anyone interested – just let me know your opinion of Jane Eyre.

_ ____ ________________

For those book-readers-and-pie-lovers who don’t already know, this work of fiction is the back story to one of the characters in Jane Eyre. Jane is the plucky poor governess who woos Rochester to marriage but then finds out that he is already married. And this first wife is living in his house, chained up in the attic! Sorry if I spoilt that for you, but I am truly shocked when I encounter people who don’t know what Jane Eyre is about. Book readers, even. How, I ask, do some college educated people I am friends with actually not know about Jane Eyre! A diverse world we live in; I keep finding out.

Anyway, Jean Rhys had read Jane Eyre and wanted to know more about this first Mrs. Rochester and so she put her ideas into this short novella.

I probably should reread it. It is atmospheric and confusing. It is stream of consciousness and vivid. It provides narrative on the lady’s childhood (tragic) and then switches to a time right after she is married to an Englishman and is this part is from this unnamed guy’s perspective. We know this is Rochester.

And he comes off as an asshole. The first part is rather straightforward and we sympathize greatly with Miss Antoinette and her sad mother and her scary circumstances – poor and friendless in hostile territory, a failed plantation on a Caribbean island. It is sketchy exactly how her fortunes turn but mother somehow remarries money… more tragedy happens and then Part 2.

Rochester marries Antoinette for her money, but doesn’t really remember everything cuz he gets the fever for a few weeks while all this is happening. Antoinette seems happy and crazy in love but Rochester is bewildered and befuddled and then finds out Antoinette’s true father was a drunk and much worse, her mother is ‘mad’, crazy, a whore. Rochester is filled with rage. He’s been tricked!

Antoinette also becomes enraged to find out this guy is a total jerk. Partly because he starts calling her Bertha – or was that before he got pissed off, I forget; but it was odd to me why he did that (and it is just so hard to think of the name Bertha as a “pretty” pet name – so confusing.) And THEN! He sleeps with a servant, UGH! and basically treats everyone like the asshole he is.

Part 3 is in England, to scenes familiar to those of us who know the setting and storyline of Jane Eyre.


Yikes… so rather than reread just yet, I post this and invite any of you to share/correct me on these thoughts.


I would love to take a class on Jane combined with discussion of this story, the history it depicts, the themes throughout both, and the motivations of both authors. Fun stuff!

The Introduction is excellent, too!

Four slices of pie. Alas, no pie nor pastry mentioned in Wide Sargasso Sea.

Cross another classic off my 50. Thank you Spin for the prompt to get this read.

I am on to my next: Vanity Fair – a classic I know little about (and what I might think I know seems to be wrong.) I know that Becky Sharpe is a famous conniving female character of literature and so far, Thackeray is entertaining in a Dickens kind of way…

[insert copyright note here and book cover image at top when I get back to a PC – I can’t figure out how to do that with this device…]


16 thoughts on “Wide Sargasso Sea #ccspin

  1. Great review. I remember being so confused by this book that I’m not sure I got that much from it. I didn’t know Edwidge Danticat had written an intro for it though, the edition I read definitely didn’t have that…love her writing!!

  2. Great review, Care! I really need to reread Jane Eyre… plan to take your advice and listen to the Thandie Newton version.

    There was a Vanity Fair read-along years ago… Melissa hosted, and Trish I think. It was a good read and it helped having friends along for the ride!

  3. So sorry to say that I never got a chance to study Jane Eyre in BSU!! Sounds darkly written. Back then the wealthy had a way of keeping SECRETS!!! What you have explained makes the book sound intriguing!! You are greatly missed as my tech engineer! Thank you for the email, too!!

    1. Aw, HELLO SALLY! I think you would like Jane Eyre. And I really really recommend the audiobook – if you like those – the one by Thandie Newton. SO GOOD.

  4. Sounds interesting! I’ve never read this but have read Jane Eyre – LONG ago in high school. It’s on my CC list as a reread. I think I’m going to try and reread it this fall. I’ve finished my Spin pick (West With the Night) and plan to write my post tonight. I am grateful to the Spin because I probably wouldn’t have gotten to it any time soon.

  5. litandlife

    To be honest, Rochester is still an ass in Jane Eyre. Why we end up caring about him is still a mystery to me. I chalk it up to the fact that Jane does so we do. I read this recently and am not sure it’s ever clear why he starts calling Antoinette Bertha – I don’t recall it being a pet name, he just decided he’d start calling her by a different name, I think.

    1. I was ambivalent abt Rochester in Jane Eyre – I will pay better attention if I read it again. Or Jane was just too nice and she convinced me she could hold her own with him?

  6. This is one of those books I keep telling myself I’m going to read…and then I don’t. I loved Jane Eyre both times I read it, and I think the whole madwoman in the attic concept fascinating (and of course kind of sad and pissy as a woman).

Welcome! I invite you to comment. If for some reason commenting is troublesome, pls send email to BkClubCare [at] Gmail

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s