The Stone Diaries

Thoughts  The Stone Diaries by Carol Shields, Penguin Books 1995, 361 pages

“Yet wherever she goes, her story marches ahead of her. Announces her. Declares and cancels her true self. Oh, she did so want to be happy, but what choice did she have, stepping to the beat of the that ragbag history of hers?

– p.122

WHAT’s it ABOUT:   I’ve been avoiding the review of this in equal measures with my enthusiasm. I loved this book. It’s funny!  Sly humor, we should say. Short sentences, deep thoughts, a bit of whimsy even. Delightful. You might even think it is a happy story from all my gushing here but that would be a lie.

Daisy Stone Goodwill Hoad Flett is just a witness to her own life. She was born to a big fat woman who didn’t even know she was pregnant and then died! Died in childbirth. Slam bam, cruel cruel world. Daisy ended up being raised by an Aunt who was really a neighbor and well, you’ll just have to read the crazy storyline if I have interested you so far. (No? oh, OK:  aunt dies, she moves with her bio-dad to Indiana from Canada, grows up & goes to school – story glosses over this part, marries but not for long (ha!), needs an adventure and ends up back in Canada married to her ‘uncle’ – yep, the original aunt’s son; has three kids, gets a job, loses job, gets depressed, gets older, moves to Florida of all places, takes a crazy trip to Scotland and and…  I won’t ruin that part – it’s quite astonishing and finally is a witness to her death and a little after.

In an interview at the back of the book – DO READ THIS, I like when I like the afterwords; so refreshing, wouldn’t you agree? Carol Shields says that many women of the generation of Daisy just fail to claim their own lives and thus never get books written about them.  So Ms Shields attempted it and was beautifully successful in writing something wholly entertaining and profound.  There, I said it. It is my opinion.

It’s the writing and the theme and the creativity and the humor that got me. I didn’t rush through this; it wasn’t a fast-paced page-turner. I savored this.

Fraidy, friend of Daisy, was my favorite. It makes me smile just to think of her letters, her words, her attitudes. Oh yes, there are letters and scattered perspectives of Daisy’s life interspersed through the entire book.

I dreaded this review because I don’t really know what to say or how to express what I loved so much. Huh, I’m at 600 words!

Or is love something less, something slippery and odorless, a transparent gas riding through the world on the back of a breeze, or else – and this is what he more and more believes – just a word trying to remember another word.


Carol Shields has me thinking she would be really fun to hang out with. I can’t wait to read more of her stories to see if she really should be one of my new favorites. If you follow my blog at all, you know I don’t tend to follow an author’s oevure. If she passes the 3 book test (3 books is when I tend to tire of an author’s ‘style’), then a favorite she will be.

WHAT’s GOOD:   Humor. I was ready for a book that made me laugh. Not that this is a funny book!  It is, but I wouldn’t classify it in that section of the library.  It’s funny in that life-is-absurd kind of way.

It is inevitable that each of us will be misunderstood; this, it seems, is part of twentieth-century wisdom.


WHAT maybe NOT so good?    Can’t think of a thing.

FINAL THOUGHTS:    [crickets]

RATING:  Five slices of pie.

… the great story she let rise up and swamp her.

– p.125

REVIEWS:   Results of Fyrefly’s Book Blog Search for this title and then the one that first brought this book to my attention:  the Bluestocking Society where she says ‘we glimpse truths about the entire human condition’. Shoutouts to Kailana and Chris of Bookarama (whatdoyouknow! Canadians) for chatting with me about this on Twitter and goodreads.  *smiles*


Copyright © 2007-2011. Care’s Online Book Club. All rights reserved. This post was originally posted by Care from Care’s Online Book Club.  It should not be reproduced without express written permission.

30 thoughts on “The Stone Diaries

  1. I am so glad you enjoyed this! I am thinking I really should reread Carol Shields, but I am always worried it will make favourite authors less of a favourite. I did notice when I looked up her bibliography to send you suggestions, though, that I have never read any of her plays.

    1. Which reminds me… I tried to add this edition to the goodreads options for this title – all because I want to see the cover I have – but I messed it up. So I applied for librarian status! Might as well, I think I can be professional about it. I now need to go fix what I screwed up.

  2. Crickets. That pretty sums up my thoughts on this book. I found it bleak–was it funny?! I read it well before blogging and I did not like the book at all BUTTTTTTTTTTT i’ve kept it on the shelf so that I can read it again one day to see if I like it better a second time (does anyone else do this?!)

    1. I said crickets because I said everything prior and had nothing left to add (stupid review format form that I use)

      Yes, it was ironic and funny. Funny to me. But NOT laughs and jokes.

      It suits my sense of humor perfectly. I am the kind of person that laughs at inappropriate times and people ask me, “What’s so funny?”

      I have read a few reviews on goodreads that people thought it NOT FUNNY AT ALL and I just have to guess that we don’t find the same things funny. YaKnow?

      1. And I used to never reread books. But since blogging, I have wanted to more. I read The Book Thief twice and loved it both times. I think it is grand of you to want to try it again at a later time.

    1. When I turned the page onto the photos, I had a slight FREAK-fest. WHA!?!??! but then, after double-checking “Yes, this is fiction.” and reading the interview, I thought it kinda cool. The pics were of the author’s kids! or she found in a second hand shop, I think.

  3. I love Carol Shields but I read all of her novels long before I started blogging. I’ve started re-reading her books and like them as much as I did before. I have, however, in more than one instance had problems with some her endings, although I can’t remember anything specific 15 years later.

    Swann is a fantastic novel and so different from her other books.

    1. OH Thank you Thank you! I want to read Swann right now NOW! Maybe when it is my pick for book club… I still have to read 1Q84 first. and I think I committed to reading the entire Harry Potty ____ whateverthereadisfor ‘every Harry Potter’. first. sigh….

  4. I’ve had this on the TBR shelf for awhile — I’m starting a new book group at my library branch and this sounds like a really good choice. Thanks for reminding me about it.

    1. I never really had that ‘read an author’s backlist’ desire until I started book blogging. I’m choosy, though. Choosy because I find I want to read so so so many books (and authors) now.

  5. I’m glad to see you enjoyed this book. I picked it up at a library sale awhile back but haven’t read it yet. I’m glad I came across your review because I didn’t know anything about this book, just grabbed it based on the blurb and cover. 😉

    1. Anna, this is one of those books that sounded good and I immediately tried to find it (and I did, on bookmooch) but then took a while to finally read. I hope you enjoy it.

  6. Pingback: BBAW Save-the-Date – Care's Books and Pie

Welcome! I invite you to comment. If for some reason commenting is troublesome, pls send email to BkClubCare [at] Gmail

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s