Thoughts
The Mermaid of Brooklyn by Amy Shearn, A Touchstone Book Published by Simon & Schuster 2013, 339 pages
For THE BOOKIES, my local book club
First Sentence: “Before I died the first time, my husband left me broke and alone with our two tiny children and it made me feel very depressed, etc.”
What’s it ABOUT: This is a story of a young mother, abandoned and sleep-deprived, who either slips off a bridge or attempts suicide and has her body invaded by the soul of a mermaid. With the help of her new friend-inside-her-head, she finds the strength she never knew she had to thrive and not just get by. But then the mermaid leaves her and her husband comes home and all is well with the world. I guess.
That’s what I got out of it anyway.
What’s GOOD: It has its funny comic moments. I think I chuckled a few times.
What’s NOT so good: The teaser in the opening sentence sets up an expectation but the subsequent pages never build up any drama; eventually I started to get bored and wanted the story to ‘get on with it already’. The mermaid’s abrupt departure is not satisfying. When someone at club stated that our poor young mother was a whiner, she was defended with a right to whine since she was exhausted and was taking care of too little exhausting kids and had no help. I suppose I would whine, too, so I’ll concede.
FINAL thoughts: The club was split; no one expressed over-the-top loving it but some did think it an enjoyable nice read; a few of us either didn’t finish, didn’t like the character or was plain not impressed. We actually had an interesting discussion debating the book; we spent more time talking about this book than most.
The mermaid is also rather ambiguous – was she ‘real’? Or … not? Interestingly enough — I *did* think this part was kind of cool — our protagonist studied Slavic folklore and Russian literature and this story element was quite effective and felt authentic. I didn’t realize mermaids were of Slavic origin.
“I lived for that twilight time when Betty snuggled up and prompted me, “Tell the fishy.” Then my oft-mocked master’s degree in Russian folklore (it sounded good at the time) got its moment to shine. “Yes,” I told Betty, working a comb through a post-bath snarl. “Once there was a fish-woman who lived at the bottom of the river. Every night she came out and danced in the meadow by the light of the moon.”
As another goodreads reviewer noted, “this book has an audience that will enjoy it immensely; I’m just not in that audience.” (thanks Jessica!)
Rating: Two slices of pie.
Words
RANUNCULUS – p.332 - noun. A temperate plant of a genus that includes the buttercups and water crowfoots, typically having yellow or white bowl-shaped flowers and lobed or toothedleaves. • Genus Ranunculus, family Ranunculaceae: many species, including several garden ornamentals.
“We sat at her dining room table, where a mason jar of sunny ranunculus held court amid a gathering of puzzle pieces. I pressed my hands to the side of the jar, hoping the goodness of the flowers could heal me.”
The next book up for club: The Witch of Little Italy
by Suzanne Palmieri. Anyone read it? (not due until August)
HIdeinWhitetoSkipLine
























The Fault In Our Stars
Published June 25, 2012 Author Recommendation , Book Club , Read in Published Year , Words , Young Adult 31 CommentsTags: a quote from Nymeth "no reduction of their pain to an inspirational example for the benefit of those of us lucky enough to be currently healthy.", amazing, Book Club, fun facts, funky names, hamartia, Hazel still reminds me of Watership Down, I have to dust off the writing/composing tools, I want to visit Amsterdam, John Green, LOVED the bit about champagne being stars which I didn't write down anywhere which is odd so feel free to comment with it or don't because I can get it today at bookclub, my current read references Watership Down, Nymeth's review is SO GOOD, The Fault In Our Stars, this was a library book, today, Watership Down is a great book to have read since so many other books bring it up
Thoughts
The Fault In Our Stars by John Green, DUTTON BOOKS An Imprint of Penguin Group 2012, 313 pages
Why I read this: For The Bookies Book Club.
Fact: This is the 4th book I’ve read by John Green. This places him in a small group. Only a few authors can claim that I’ve read more than 3 of their books. (yea, like any are keeping track.)
I enjoyed this book very much, finding all that I love about John Green’s books to be included; the words I don’t know and then are defined within the conversation so I don’t have to look it up, travels, the loving well-meaning and usually respected parents, the reckless rule-breaking but not quite tragic and always smart teenagers, and yes – I take it back – the tragic. But always ends with a good cry and tons of hope that life really doesn’t have to suck even it if does. I don’t quite know how he does it.
I don’t have my “THOUGHTS” post-writing skills yet dusted off so I won’t tell you what this book is about. It often gets debated that it is about cancer and that appalls some and thus they want to avoid it but cancer is everywhere and what we need to know how to do is – uh oh, I’m preaching?! – is to learn how to relate to people through the good and the bad. I loved how this book does that. With humor, with love and with respect.
I also resent the implications of some of the goodreads reviews that seem to question Green’s authority to write a book about kids with cancer and think it is totally unequivocally absurd.
Here are more reviews or you can click on the book cover above and read the goodreads.com stuff.
Nymeth says, the author ‘hoped this would be a novel that would make readers feel ALL THE THINGS, and I think it succeeds very impressively on that regard.’ Her review is actually quite brilliant and I always learn so much from her. Truly, I want to quote from every one of her paragraphs.
Softdrink had a few problems with the book and her points are valid. She also references another review so you may want to follow that trail.
and Ti’s review where she simply says, “An amazing, life affirming read.”.
.
I think my favorite of the JG novels will forever be Looking for Alaska; I still had to rate this 5 slices of pie. I rounded up since I don’t give half slices…
HIdeinWhitetoSkipLine