I had so many lines typed up in my last post that I kept deleting… And then BeastMomma said it sounded depressing that I realized that I just didn’t do right in that post, my quick review of Still Life with Elephants by J R Singer. In an even earlier post, I promised a fair review.
So, I thought I would try again.
This book was NOT depressing. Just not to my liking. It’s actually amusing and good-hearted and has quite a few funny comic moments. There happen to be many references to music and books and authors and horsey things that I don’t know which suggest that it is of a higher level than typical ‘chick lit’ – which is the genre I would place this book. But that makes me feel snobbish. Or the reverse snobbish… Or… [see why I keep typing and deleting?!?!?!]
Despite the depressing description of what happens to Neelie (cad of a husband, no money, etc), she happens to FIND HERSELF and a love for cute baby elephants AND gets to fall in love with the rich guy! That’s not depressing, right?
Just because the rich guy offers to rescue her and buy her house, she has the self-respect to say no and find a way to keep respecting herself, her talents, her independence. She won’t say yes to his marriage proposal until she knows she is accepting for love and not the need to be rescued. She will, however, accept his job offer to chase elephants in Africa. Which is more uprooting than marriage, imho. I mean, really. She won’t marry him because he tells her he doesn’t want children? Yet she agrees to run all over the world and live dangerously in Africa?!?! Hrmmmph.
She annoyed me with her ability to misconstrue words people where saying. It was NOT endearing – it was distracting. And I couldn’t believe the stupid husband was so stupid and then wanted to be forgiven. AND, I thought the book treated mental illness a tad too flippantly and with disrespect to bipolar sufferers.
And I can’t believe she got away with eating jelly donuts everyday. I mean really.
On the other hand, girl is wronged by stupid husband, girl wises up and lands on her feet, finds new career AND gets the rich guy.
Maybe I just wasnt’ in the mood for chicklit. I regret that I presented a review that made it seem like it was a depressing story. The book jacket says it is a ”…funny, heartwarming story.” There you have it.
Recent Comments